Dexter "The Getaway"

The Getaway is the season finale of the fourth season of Dexter; an up and down season highlighted by John Lithgow's performance as Arthur Mitchell the Trinity Killer. The finale was a microcosm of the show; an anti-climactic cat and mouse chase that manges to be incredibly entertaining in spite of obvious plot holes.

Throughout this season there was sloppy writing and plotting that led to clear plot holes. These plot holes may get resolved next season, but I am doubt it. Before this season Dexter (the character) was always incredibly meticulous, but he suddenly became incredibly sloppy. Dexter sloppiness was a conscious choice by the writers, but it was frequently illustrated in such a cartoonish way that it challenged my suspension of disbelief. The most egregious example this season was Dexter assuming he could kill Trinity and have the Mitchell family ignore Kyle Butler's sudden entry and disappearance from their life. I am not a detective, but when someone shows up at your house demanding to find the location of someone* he is usually a suspect when said person disappears. In the finale Dexter going to the Mitchell house was a slight stretch, but one I could buy, however Dexter being in the Mitchell family's line of sight as they are getting put in the backseat of a cop car was too unbelievable. That was done to create a good shot, but it still really lazy directing; that reminds the viewer that they are watching a work of fiction. Something contrived like having him behind a tree would have been a significant improvement over the decision made by the director.

*Someone whose throat he held a knife in front of the whole family a couple week agos.

The writers and Dexter's sloppiness were clear from the very beginning of the episode when Dexter's tracked Trinity leaving the police station. He didn't choose to follow him in the traditional stealthy serial killer we'd expect of Dexter. He just ran outside of the police station hopped into his car and chased him. That is the same strategy I use in GTA IV when I need to follow people. Dexter's "plan" and Trinity being unaware of the maniac in the SUV following him through traffic were equally implausible and this is a show about superhero serial killer. Again I realize Dexter was supposed to be losing control, but there is a fine line between making small mistakes like not doing due diligence when killing the photographer and chasing someone you are about to kill in downtown Miami in the middle of the day.

Dexter finally getting Trinity on his kill table was a fantastic scene that was really well acted by both Michael C. Hall and Lithgow, after seeing the Rita in the bathtub I rewatched the kill scene to see how the kill scene would play differently andI was pretty underwhelmed. It seemed like the scene was intentionally written in an ambiguous way to make the twist at the end as shocking as possible, instead of writing the confrontation that these two characters deserved to have.

All of that being said I have really high hopes for S5. One of the biggest problems Dexter has had is that deep down everyone knows Dexter will never get caught because they want to continue the show. This has caused the third and fourth seasons to be pretty formulaic. Dexter finds serial killer spends all season hunting him, kills him the finale or the penultimate episode and manages to express everything he learned in a monologue at the end of the season. Next season should be a paradigm shift because of Rita's death and Deb's discovery about Dexter's past. The main arc should be very different from previous seasons, Dexter will get caught and will need to find a solution that doesn't involve killing the people who find out. I hope next season is the the final season because the S4 finale has laid the ground work for a great final season. Unfortunately I am afraid that Showtime won't want to kill their golden goose and will create mediocre seasons until the show fades into mediocrity. Hopefully I am wrong and next season lives up to the hype that was created by the S4 finale.

Stray thoughts

Although relatively minor, the most annoying part of episode was the Miami PD outrage when the FBI takes over the case. Higher agency screws up earlier and takes all the credit has become an awful cliche when satirizing cop dramas. For it to actually be used in a good cop drama with no twist or irony was painful to watch.

The narration and Harry scenes are frequently a really lazy way to tell the viewers something instead of showing it to them. It has become a crutch that can be unbearable.

A major theme of the show has been Dexter's moral ambiguity; I think the writers missed a huge opportunity by turning Dexter killing an innocent man into a footnote, when it should have been a major plot point.